Share

Government’s new Environment Act targets defy public opinion on polluted rivers and wildlife recovery

The Wildlife Trusts are appalled that Government ignores public’s plea to improve river health and protected places – and allows nature to flatline for next 20 years

Today, the Government unveiled their overdue domestic environmental targets while taking the stage at the international nature conference, COP15, where negotiators are attempting to agree a global deal for nature’s recovery.

The long-awaited Environment Act targets are intended to improve biodiversity, air and water quality, and reduce waste. But instead, nature will continue to struggle as the Government’s low ambition defies public opinion on river health, wildlife declines and sites for nature. Without improving our protected wild places, it will be impossible for the UK to meet its international commitment to protecting 30% of land and sea for nature by 2030.

Of particular concern in today’s announcement are:

  • There is no overall target to improve water quality – The Wildlife Trusts called for a target for at least 75% of rivers, streams and other freshwater bodies to reach an overall “clean waters” status by 2042 – without this we could see improvements on a few specific pollutants while others, including plastics and pesticides, continue to pour into our rivers and seas, threatening wildlife and human health.
  • There is no target to improve the condition of protected nature areas – despite calls for 75% of protected wildlife sites to be in favourable condition by 2042.
  • The targets set for wildlife abundance will fail to reverse decades of species declines – instead recovery will flatline.
  • Increased conifer planting will not help natural habitats and wildlife to recover. It will also fail to store carbon for the longer term as trees are chopped down and burnt as biofuels.

Currently, the UK is one of the most nature-depleted nations in the world, where almost one in 10 species are at risk of extinction. Despite this, the Government has proposed that by 2042, nature will be in a similar condition to our current depleted state. In England, for example, every freshwater body currently fails chemical standards.

Craig Bennett

Craig Bennett (c) Trai Anfield

Craig Bennett, chief executive of The Wildlife Trusts, says:

“We were told that these targets were delayed to take into account the unprecedented public response to the consultation – but despite 99% of respondents calling for greater ambition to reverse nature’s decline, we’ve ended up with the same low ambition targets that were consulted on. What’s more, the Government has failed to set targets on two of the most pressing issues – river health and protected sites for nature.

“Not a single river, lake, or estuary in England is in good health – with sewage, agricultural and chemical pollution continuing to pour into our waterways. And the Government’s latest data on the state of nature shows that the condition of our most important places for wildlife is continuing to decline year on year. Failing to set targets to tackle these fundamental issues defies public opinion. Without a target to improve our protected sites, the Government has little hope of achieving its international commitment to protect 30% of land for nature by 2030.

“The target to halt nature’s decline by the end of the decade is welcome but this should be coupled with a genuine target for nature’s recovery. Simply aiming for marginally more nature in 20 years’ time than our current, extremely depleted state is far from world-leading and an abdication of our responsibility to future generations.”

The Wildlife Trusts called for ambitious targets and over 60,000 of our supporters echoed this call. But instead, today, the Government have published the same weak targets that we were originally consulted on.

The Environmental Targets were promised in the Conservative Party’s 2019 manifesto and described as a “key commitment” of the Environment Act. The Government missed its deadline to release the targets by the 31st October and is at risk of missing the legal deadline to publish a new environmental improvement plan, required under the Environment Act, by the end of January 2023.

The lack of ambition for nature recovery in the UK is the latest blow dealt by Government for wildlife and wild places. It continues to press on with the Retained EU Law Bill, which threatens over a thousand laws that protect the environment, including those that afford legal protections for habitats and species, and ensure minimum standards for water quality and pollution.

The UN Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) has proposed that at least 30% of the world’s land and seas should be protected by 2030 to prevent the destruction of the planet’s biodiversity. While the UK committed to this ambition in 2020, the latest progress report by Wildlife & Countryside Link shows just 3.22% of the UK’s land and 8% of the sea are well protected and managed for nature.

The decline of nature undermines our future ability to grow food, have enough clean water and air, and survive in a warming world. The poor state of natural habitats is intrinsically linked to the climate crisis – restored habitats store carbon and degraded habitats emit carbon. Putting nature into recovery is fundamental for people and wildlife to adapt to a changing climate.

Editor’s notes

Blueprint for water report (2021)

Research found that every freshwater body in England currently fails chemical standards and only 16% are classed in good ecological health compared to 53% on average in the EU. Read the press release here and report here.

Earlier this year, The Wildlife Trusts proposed three major changes should be made to the proposed Environment Act targets – we continue to stand by these:

  • A stronger species abundance target: The target to increase the abundance of wildlife by 10% by 2042 compared to 2030 levels is too weak and uncertain. If, as expected, wildlife continues to decline for the rest of the decade, it could mean that wildlife is less abundant by 2042 than it is now. This falls short of the Government’s promise to pass nature to the next generation in better condition. Instead, the Government should set a target to increase the abundance of marine and terrestrial species by at least 20% by 2042 compared to 2022 levels.
  • A target for protected sites condition: The extent and quality of habitats are crucial to nature’s recovery. At the moment, just 38% of SSSIs in England are in favourable condition, despite being some of the most precious sites for nature. Yet the Government has not proposed a statutory target to improve the state of protected sites, despite its commitment in the 25 Year Environment Plan to ensure that three quarters are in good condition. The Government should set a habitats target for at least 75% of our finest wildlife sites (SSSIs) to be in favourable condition by 2042.
  • An overall target for water: We have some of the worst-quality rivers in Europe. Pollution from agriculture, sewage, roads and plastics is destroying freshwater habitats and making our rivers dangerous for both humans and wildlife. Currently River Basin Management Plans set out actions for improvement, but after 2027 it’s unclear whether there will be any overall target or framework holding the Government to account. The four targets now published could mean we see improvements in pollution from particular sources, whilst the overall health of our rivers, lakes, estuaries and coasts continues to decline.
  • In particular, aspects of agricultural water pollution are overlooked and the target for water companies does not cover nitrates or sewage overflows. The Government should set a long-term “outcome” target for at least 75% of rivers, streams and other freshwater bodies to reach an overall “clean waters” status by 2042, in addition to stronger targets for pollution reduction and abstraction reduction.

 

The Wildlife Trusts

The Wildlife Trusts are making the world wilder and helping to ensure that is nature is part of everyone’s lives. We are a grassroots movement of 46 charities with more than 850,000 members and 38,000 volunteers. No matter where you are in Britain, there is a Wildlife Trust inspiring people and saving, protecting, and standing up for the natural world. With the support of our members, we care for and restore special places for nature on land and run marine conservation projects and collect vital data on the state of our seas. Every Wildlife Trust works within its local community to inspire people to create a wilder future – from advising thousands of landowners on how to manage their land to benefit wildlife, to connecting hundreds of thousands of school children with nature every year. 

Related news